ADVICE Josh Taylor. November 16, 2026
Short answer: in most of San Diego, renting is cheaper month to month right now. Buying usually costs a lot more each month on day one. It wins over time if you stay long enough, your income can absorb the gap, and you buy the right property.
This is the question I get asked most over coffee. So here's how I actually walk clients through it, with real numbers.
Rent in San Diego has been flat to slightly up this year. Zillow's rent index put the typical asking rent at about $2,890 a month in March 2026, up 1.4% from a year earlier. Trulia's May 2026 data shows an average of $4,390 a month for a 3 bedroom rental.
So for a family looking at a 3 bedroom house, $4,000 to $4,500 a month is a realistic rent number in many central neighborhoods.
Mortgage rates are the big swing factor. Freddie Mac's weekly average for a 30 year fixed was 7.18% on November 5, 2026, compared with 6.22% a year earlier.
Here's a working estimate for a $1,000,000 home, about the typical value in the City of San Diego, with 20% down:
Monthly cost | Estimate |
|---|---|
Principal and interest ($800K loan at 7.18%) | $5,419 |
Property tax (about 1.2% of price) | $1,000 |
Homeowners insurance | $170 |
Total before maintenance | about $6,590 |
Add a maintenance budget on top. On an older Craftsman in North Park or South Park, I'd plan for more than on a newer build.
Compare that to a $4,400 rent on a similar house and you're looking at roughly $2,000 to $2,200 more a month to own.
Because the monthly payment isn't the whole story. A few things work in an owner's favor over time:
The monthly comparison leaves out the biggest factor: what the house is worth when you're done.
San Diego's long-term track record is hard to ignore. The S&P Case-Shiller index for San Diego, which starts at 100 in January 2000, stood at 446.60 in February 2026. That means a typical San Diego home has roughly quadrupled in price since 2000, about 5.9% a year on average. The FHFA's index for the San Diego metro tells a similar story going back to 1995, about 5.8% a year.
That average includes the 2008 crash and this year's flat stretch. Case-Shiller showed San Diego up just 0.54% year over year in February 2026. Appreciation comes in waves, not a straight line.
Here's the same $1,000,000 purchase with 20% down at 7.18%, held for 10 years. After 10 years of payments you'd have paid the loan down by about $110,000 on top of any appreciation.
Annual appreciation | Home value in 10 years | Your equity in 10 years |
|---|---|---|
3% (a slow decade) | about $1.34M | about $655,000 |
4% | about $1.48M | about $790,000 |
5.8% (the long-term average) | about $1.76M | about $1.07M |
You started with $200,000 down. Even in the slow scenario, your equity more than triples.
To be fair to renting, you'd subtract selling costs, the roughly $2,000 a month extra you paid to own, and whatever a renter earns by investing their down payment instead. In a slow decade, the gap between owning and renting can be close. At anything near San Diego's historic pace, owning usually comes out well ahead.
Think of the extra monthly cost as a forced savings plan with leverage. You're putting in 20%, but you get the appreciation on 100% of the house.
Appreciation sources: Case-Shiller San Diego index · FHFA San Diego metro HPI. Past appreciation doesn't guarantee future results.
I'll tell clients to keep renting when:
Renting isn't throwing money away. It buys flexibility, and that has real value.
Buying usually wins when:
Some of my clients don't pick one or the other. They buy a duplex in an area like Normal Heights or Ocean Beach, live in one unit and rent the other. Others buy a home with space for an ADU in Clairemont or Bay Park and build later.
These strategies won't fit everyone, but they change the math more than anything else I've seen.
If you're asking whether buying is cheaper this month, it usually isn't right now. A better question is whether owning gets you somewhere renting can't over the next 10 years. For many of my clients it does. For some it doesn't yet, and that's a fine answer too.
Month to month, renting is usually cheaper at today's rates. Redfin estimated a household needs about $231,000 a year to buy a typical San Diego home, versus about $116,000 to rent a typical apartment (December 2025 data).
There's no single number. As a rule of thumb, I want buyers planning to stay at least 5 years, ideally 7 or more.
Nobody can time rates. If you buy the right home at a payment you can live with, you can refinance later. If you wait, you can't go back and buy at today's price.
If you're on the fence, I'm happy to run the numbers on your actual budget and the neighborhoods you're looking at, with no pressure either way. Sometimes the right answer is "keep renting for another year," and I'll tell you that too. Reach out anytime.
Stay up to date on the latest trends in real estate.
November 16, 2026
Real monthly numbers at today's rates, plus what San Diego appreciation means over 10 years
November 16, 2026
Income and cash to close at today's rates, from a $650K condo to a $1.25M house
November 3, 2026
How The Carmine Collection manages a few select San Diego homes, what it costs, and the STRO rules every owner should know
November 3, 2026
How living upstairs and renting the lock-off downstairs under a home sharing license covered my mortgage
November 3, 2026
The research report, the criteria, the hearing, and what changes after.
November 2, 2026
What running The Carmine Collection taught me about selling homes.
October 28, 2026
Where to live near each San Diego base and major employer, and how a VA loan turns BAH into equity
October 28, 2026
How bonus depreciation, Tier 3 licenses and motivated sellers line up before December 31
October 17, 2026
The Modernist Weekend: Four Architect-Designed Homes Worth the Drive
Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact Josh today.