ADVICE Josh Taylor. November 20, 2026
My partner Joe and I own four short-term rentals in San Diego: a beach townhome, a Victorian manor, a tropical villa and a suite in a building we're still restoring. Together they make up The Carmine Collection, named after Joe's middle name.
I sell real estate for a living, so I could have bought the obvious Airbnb: a big house near the beach with a hot tub and a lot of beds. We didn't. Every home we own is one guests book for the home itself. Here's what each one is, what the numbers look like this year, and what owning them has taught us about buying a short-term rental in San Diego.
Casa Coolangatta, Mission Beach. My first property, and the one I renovated myself. It's a two-bedroom, two-bath townhome steps from the sand, with vaulted ceilings, exposed wood beams, zellige tile and Venetian plaster. I lived upstairs while the downstairs ran as its own Airbnb under a home-sharing license. After a few years on the Mission Beach waitlist, our whole-home license came through, so I moved out and now the full townhome rents to couples and families. Read how I split my townhome to qualify for the license.
The Jade Manor, close to downtown. A Victorian with a Mills Act contract, reworked by Joe with an editorial eye. It's our group home, built for girls' trips, bachelorettes and birthdays, and it was hand-selected by Plum Guide.
Kirra Villa. An outdoor tropical compound with an alfresco clawfoot tub and The Birdcage, an Art Deco speakeasy. Condé Nast Traveler has named it one of the best Airbnbs in San Diego four years in a row. It's for design lovers and small celebrations.
The Bordeaux Suite at The Brunswick, South Park. The first finished piece of The Brunswick, a building Joe and I are restoring. The suite has been booking since March, and the rest of the building comes next.
Our two longest-running homes are both ahead of last year. From January through October, Kirra Villa's rental revenue is up 33% on the same months of 2025, and The Jade Manor is up 9%.
Home | Booking since | Avg. nightly rate, 2026 | Avg. occupancy, 2026 | Revenue vs 2025, Jan to Oct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
The Jade Manor | Before 2025 | $977 | 59% | Up 9% |
Kirra Villa | Before 2025 | $567 | 65% | Up 33% |
Casa Coolangatta (whole home) | July 2026 | $743 | 45% | New |
The Bordeaux Suite | March 2026 | $202 | 60% | New |
Notice what's missing: none of these homes runs at 80% or 90% occupancy, and that's on purpose. We price high and fill fewer nights with better guests. The Jade Manor averaged over $1,700 a night in July. Fewer turnovers mean less wear, fewer neighbor complaints and more time to get every stay right.
Figures are our own, from PriceLabs, with monthly averages across months the home was booking. Every home and every year is different, so treat them as examples, not projections.
The license is the asset. Casa Coolangatta took years on the Mission Beach waitlist before it could rent as a whole home. Before you buy, know exactly which license the home needs and whether one is available, because licenses don't transfer with a sale.
Design is the marketing. Kirra Villa's press didn't come from ads. It came from a clawfoot tub under the sky and a hidden speakeasy. Joe's construction and design background is the reason our homes photograph the way they do.
Every home needs one clear guest. Casa is for beach couples and families. Kirra Villa is for design lovers and small celebrations. The Jade Manor is for groups. When a home tries to be for everyone, the photos, the price and the reviews all get muddy.
Old homes are worth the work, with a plan. The Jade Manor's Mills Act contract lowers its property taxes in exchange for restoring it over time, including swapping metal window frames for wood over ten years. Historic homes cost more to keep, but guests remember them.
Pricing is a daily job. We use PriceLabs on every listing. Rates move with the season, events and how far ahead someone books, and a flat rate leaves money on the table.
Systems beat heroics. Hospitable runs our messaging and calendars, each home has its own guest guide, and we're adding channels like Booking.com. When you own four homes, nothing can depend on you remembering it.
If you're thinking about your first San Diego short-term rental, here's where I'd start:
Owning these homes is also why I can help investors buy their own. I've run the waitlists, the licenses, the renovations and the pricing myself. If you're looking at a short-term rental in San Diego, let's talk before you write an offer.
Stay up to date on the latest trends in real estate.
November 20, 2026
What to check on licenses, neighbors, head count and fire insurance before you buy a destination home.
November 20, 2026
Our four short-term rentals, their 2026 numbers, and what they've taught us about buying one in San Diego.
November 16, 2026
Real monthly numbers at today's rates, plus what San Diego appreciation means over 10 years
November 16, 2026
Income and cash to close at today's rates, from a $650K condo to a $1.25M house
November 3, 2026
How The Carmine Collection manages a few select San Diego homes, what it costs, and the STRO rules every owner should know
November 3, 2026
How living upstairs and renting the lock-off downstairs under a home sharing license covered my mortgage
November 3, 2026
The research report, the criteria, the hearing, and what changes after.
November 2, 2026
What running The Carmine Collection taught me about selling homes.
October 28, 2026
Where to live near each San Diego base and major employer, and how a VA loan turns BAH into equity
Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact Josh today.