ADVICE Josh Taylor. November 22, 2026
Here's the short version. In San Diego, you should get a real homeowners insurance quote in the first few days of escrow, well before you remove contingencies. Don't wait until the week before closing.
A few years ago insurance was the last thing on the checklist. Your lender asked for it, you called the company that insures your car, and that was it. Those days are over. I now have insurance on my list for the first week of every escrow, right next to the inspection.
This guide covers what's changed, what it means for buyers here, and the steps I walk my clients through so the insurance quote doesn't blow up their budget at the last minute.
The cost of homeowners insurance has climbed fast. A Stanford study released in June found that California homeowners insurance premiums are up 84% since 2020.
Availability is the other half of the problem. After big wildfire losses, several major carriers stopped writing new policies or cut back where they would write. Over the same period, FAIR Plan enrollment has nearly tripled, from under 2% to 5% of homes.
San Diego hasn't escaped this. Based on FAIR Plan data, San Diego County had 59,063 FAIR Plan policies, a 379% increase. This isn't limited to the backcountry, either. Reporting from inewsource found nonrenewals were most prominent in the county's rural areas but also affecting city neighborhoods from Scripps Ranch to Hillcrest.
There are some real signs that it is, but it's not fixed.
The catch is price. The new state rules let carriers raise rates in exchange for writing more policies in high-risk areas, so expect more options at higher premiums. The FAIR Plan itself is more expensive now too: it raised rates by 29.1% starting October 15, 2026.
You have a contractual window for this. Most San Diego deals are written on the California Association of Realtors purchase agreement. Under it, the investigation contingency gives the buyer the right to check out the neighborhood, crime statistics, schools, the availability and cost of insurance, among other things. The newer version of the form also adds a specific contingency for insurance.
The default contingency timeline is 17 days after acceptance. In a competitive offer, though, buyers often shorten that window, and that's when insurance gets dangerous. If you remove contingencies and then find out the only option is a FAIR Plan policy for $9,000 a year, you either absorb the cost or risk your deposit.
Here's the timeline I give my buyers:
In my experience, these are the factors that most often cause trouble with a quote.
Canyons are one of the best parts of living in San Diego. They're also what carriers look at first. Homes backing onto canyons in neighborhoods like Kensington, South Park, Mission Hills and Tierrasanta can get very different quotes from a house two blocks away.
Look at the Natural Hazard Disclosure early. If the home is in a Very High Fire Hazard Severity Zone, get the insurance conversation started on day one.
I work with a lot of historic homes, and this is where buyers get caught off guard. Carriers often hesitate over or decline:
None of these has to kill the deal. They're things you negotiate, and sometimes they need to be fixed before close for the policy to bind. A seller credit for rewiring is a much better outcome than learning about the problem in week three.
Ask the seller for their CLUE report, the database of past insurance claims on the property. A history of water claims can affect your quote, and the report can reveal problems that never showed up in the disclosures.
If you end up on the FAIR Plan, it's not the end of the world, but understand what it is. It is basic property insurance covering specific perils, such as fire. It is not a full homeowners policy.
That's why most FAIR Plan homeowners add a second policy. As the FAIR Plan explains, its policy can be supplemented with a Difference in Conditions policy available through the voluntary market. A DIC policy fills in the gaps, such as liability, theft and water damage.
The way I'd think about it: the FAIR Plan is a spare tire. It gets you home, but you don't want to drive on it forever. The state describes it the same way, as a temporary safety net, so keep shopping even after the policy is in place.
There's also proposed legislation to change the FAIR Plan, including implementing a more comprehensive homeowners coverage option like other insurance companies. As of mid-2026 that bill was still moving through the Legislature, so check its status before assuming it applies to you.
California's Safer from Wildfires program requires insurers to offer discounts for specific improvements, and every action under Safer from Wildfires will qualify you for an insurance discount. The top items include:
The FAIR Plan offers its own version. Homeowners who complete all of its listed measures may see a discount of up to 16.4% off the wildfire portion of their policy premium.
If you're buying a home that needs a new roof anyway, this is a strong reason to go with a Class A material and get the credit from the seller.
Condos: You'll need your own HO-6 policy, but the HOA's master policy matters just as much. Ask for it during escrow. Look at who the carrier is, whether the building is on the FAIR Plan, and what the master deductible is. If the HOA is underinsured, every owner can end up paying a special assessment. Make sure your HO-6 includes loss assessment coverage.
Rentals and STRs: A standard homeowners policy usually won't cover a property you rent out. Long-term rentals need a landlord (dwelling fire) policy. Short-term rentals need coverage written specifically for that use. As an STR owner myself, I'd tell any investor to price this into the numbers from the start, because it can change whether a property cash flows.
This matters for sellers and current owners too. In California, an insurer must give a 75-day notice containing the reason or reasons for the nonrenewal. Call a broker as soon as you get it. Seventy-five days goes quickly, especially if you're trying to sell.
How much is homeowners insurance in San Diego?
It depends heavily on location, the age of the home and wildfire exposure. A newer coastal condo and a 1920s Craftsman on a canyon edge can be thousands of dollars apart. Get a quote for the specific address.
Can I buy a house in San Diego if I can only get the FAIR Plan?
Yes. Many lenders accept a FAIR Plan policy paired with a DIC policy, but confirm with your lender early.
Does my lender require insurance before closing?
Yes. Your lender will require proof of hazard insurance before funding the loan.
Is insurance easier to get near the coast?
Often, but not always. Coastal homes can still be hard to insure because of their age or their claims history.
Insurance is now part of underwriting the house, not a box you check at the end. Get quotes early, go through the inspection with insurance in mind, and don't remove contingencies until you know what you'll be paying.
If you're buying in San Diego and want help figuring out whether a home is insurable before you commit, reach out. I'm happy to walk you through it and introduce you to brokers I trust.
Stay up to date on the latest trends in real estate.
November 22, 2026
How to spot each style, where to find it, and what to check before you buy
November 22, 2026
How to get insured early in escrow, what the FAIR Plan covers, and how to keep premiums down
November 20, 2026
What to check on licenses, neighbors, head count and fire insurance before you buy a destination home.
November 20, 2026
Our four short-term rentals, their 2026 numbers, and what they've taught us about buying one in San Diego.
November 16, 2026
Real monthly numbers at today's rates, plus what San Diego appreciation means over 10 years
November 16, 2026
Income and cash to close at today's rates, from a $650K condo to a $1.25M house
November 3, 2026
How The Carmine Collection manages a few select San Diego homes, what it costs, and the STRO rules every owner should know
November 3, 2026
How living upstairs and renting the lock-off downstairs under a home sharing license covered my mortgage
November 3, 2026
The research report, the criteria, the hearing, and what changes after.
Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact Josh today.